| 2004 | Tom Gorshe (1970) - Law and Government |
| John Huston (1975) - Sports | |
| Linda Kahl Rataiczak (1964) - Education | |
| Steve Sorvalis (1959) - Business | |
| 2003 | Gio Edward Liberati (1982) - Sports |
| James B. Piatt (1953) - Civic | |
| Tony Piehowicz (1966) - Education | |
| 2002 | Danielle Frizzi (1995) - Broadcast Journalism |
| Daniel A. Giffin (1941) - Business | |
| Sons of Italy - Community Service | |
| Benny Taylor (1997) - Sports | |
| 2001 | Richard (Chad) Balwanz (1970) - Law/Government |
| Dennis Delbert (1976) - Sports | |
| Dusty Holt (1995) - Technical | |
| Linda Wilson Johnson (1969) - Business | |
| Thomas Poe (1968) - Business | |
| Frank Renzi (1949) - Civic | |
| Shawn Valloric (1994) - Technical | |
| 2000 | W. Meek Duvall (1947) - Civic |
| Miriam Wehe Irwin (1958) - Education | |
| Melvin F. Sankovich (1945) - Nuclear Power | |
| Jay Shultz (1992) - Arts | |
| 1999 | Patricia S. Ferrick (1962) - Education |
| Myron F. Greene (1958) - Business/Education/Research | |
| Michael Imbroscio (1986) - Law/Government | |
| Glenn Maxwell (1954) - Civic | |
| Bruce Stolz (1967) - Sports | |
| Adelaide Halliday Warren (1949) - Arts | |
| 1998 | The Bauknecht Family - Business/Civic |
| Nevo Capitina (1938) - Law | |
| Judy Thomas Hinton (1965) - Civic | |
| Helen Talbott (1923) - Education | |
| 1997 | Richard D. Danford (1930) - Civic |
| Jerry Fisher (1955) - Government/Civic | |
| Joey Galloway (1990) - Sports | |
| Idora Davis Kimbro (1969) - Education | |
| Thomas A. Noice (1940) - Business | |
| Carolyn M. Presutti (1978) - Journalism | |
| 1996 | Charles H. Dankworth, IV (1943) - Business |
| Marilyn Housley (1946) - Art | |
| Brenda Bella Hughes (1970) - Education | |
| Tal Hutchins (1968) - Government/Education | |
| Rev. Paul A. Johnson (1943) - Civic | |
| William (BeeBee) Marinacci (1966) - Sports | |
| 1995 | Alan Banker (1950) |
| Yolanda Caiazza Ingram (1935) | |
| Randy L. Marple (1977) | |
| Gary "Ernie" Shaver (1971) | |
| 1994 | Douglas B. Allen (1971) |
| Nancy Thornton Fry (1957) | |
| Robert Kovalyk (1955) | |
| Stephen M. Shallcross (1972) | |
| Bernard N. Walker (1961) | |
| 1988 | Terry Allen Wallace (1965) |